Which Star Sparkled More in Moschino?

Tara Reid simply sparkled in the Moschino sequined dress that she wore to Macy's Passport 2008 Gala on September 25. The "American Pie" actress has had more than her fair share of fashion flubs, so I was pleasantly surprised that she opted to wear the tasteful tiered frock to the event, which raises awareness and money for HIV/AIDS organizations.

Unfortunately, teen queen Miley Cyrus rocked the same dress on the 2008 Teen Choice Awards blue carpet and couldn't have looked cuter. If only she hadn't paired it with those gray suede boots, which kind of ruined the ensemble for me. What do you think?